Sounds Too Perfect

An essay by Chad Schomber

There used to be a squeak in the kick pedal.

You’d hear it in the third verse, usually. Some drummer sweating through a polyester shirt in a hot room. The foot pump on the bass drum would creak just a bit. A human noise. Not a mistake. Just a sign that someone was trying. You don't hear that anymore.

Modern music is a mirror polished to blindness. Everything mastered to within an inch of its life. Vocals pressed flat and shiny. Guitars run through ten filters to smooth out the soul. And drums? Digital. Clean enough to eat off. Sanitary like a hospital bed. All the oxygen sucked out. No hiss. No hum. No wheeze of a dusty amp in a carpeted corner.

People will say that’s progress. Cleaner is better. Tighter. Louder. But it’s also dishonest. Like someone showing up to dinner in a brand-new white suit and refusing to sit down. No stains. No stories.

There’s a kind of truth that only lives in the flaws. And we've started evicting it.

The Gospel According to Grit

I once heard an old recording where the singer coughed in the middle of a line. Not a big one. Just a little throat tickle. He didn’t stop. Kept right on through. That cough said more about the song than the lyrics ever could. This wasn’t a performance. This was a person.

Now? You don’t even hear breath. They scrub the inhale out of the track like it’s a sin. Like it breaks the illusion. But breath is the body talking. You ever try to cry without breathing? Try to confess something real without that half-second of shaky air before the words come out?

We’ve mistaken polish for power. Confused loud with true.

The Lie of Perfection

The problem with flawless music is that nothing sticks. You listen. It hits all the right notes. But it doesn't land anywhere. Doesn’t bruise. Doesn’t tug. It doesn’t risk anything.

Great music should feel like someone saying too much in the kitchen after midnight. Slurring a little. Saying something they maybe shouldn’t. But they had to. It should feel lived in. Worn at the elbows. Dirty around the cuffs. A little embarrassing.

But now everything sounds like it was recorded by someone trying not to sweat. With 43 takes and a plugin that smooths out the throat too much to ever say something honest.

You can’t tell a good ghost story in fluorescent light. And you can’t tell a good heartbreak over beats that snap too clean.

The Human Frequency

There’s a frequency people forgot to measure. Somewhere between 200 Hz and grief. That pitch where a voice cracks—not because the singer can’t hit the note, but because the emotion breaks the form. The ghost in the machine. And you can’t autotune it.

Every pop song now sounds like a product demo. Like it’s trying to prove it can survive a conference room. Designed for algorithms. Built for playlists. Engineered to keep people from pressing skip. But what kind of art tries to be skipped over less instead of remembered more?

Songs used to haunt. Now they just play.

The Squeak Matters

That kick pedal squeak. It’s not just nostalgia. It’s not a gimmick. It’s what makes you feel like the person playing the drums also pays rent and gets gas and maybe once loved someone who didn’t love them back.

When you wipe that out, you don't just clean the track. You sterilize the experience.

It’s the same reason folks don’t trust someone whose hands are too soft. They haven’t lifted anything real.

Where the Dirt Lives

You want to know where the stories are? They’re in the second-take vocals with the hiccup. In the bass buzz. In the floor creak when the background singer leans in too far. In the clatter of a ring hitting the mic stand.

And yeah, it’s messier. Harder to sell. You can’t loop it into infinity and call it a banger. But it lasts. Because it feels.

We remember the scratch in the record more than the song sometimes.

Let It Break a Little

Give me the singer who runs out of breath before the chorus ends. The guitar that goes slightly out of tune in the heat. The studio hum. The dog bark in the background if it’s real.

Because life isn’t quantized. Pain doesn’t hit on the downbeat. And love sure as hell doesn’t stay in key.

Let it break a little. Let it bleed. That’s where the story lives. That’s where we live.

We are not built for perfection. We’re built for resonance. For echo. For noise.

Let the music be human again.

Let the squeak stay.

---